Cases3308957/2022

Claimant v Yourway Transport Limited

25 September 2025Before Employment Judge Isabel ManleyReadingremote video

Outcome

Partly successful£94,283

Individual claims

Direct Discrimination(age)failed

The tribunal found no evidence of direct discrimination because of the claimant's age. The claim was dismissed in its entirety.

Unfair Dismissalsucceeded

The claimant was dismissed by reason of redundancy but the dismissal was procedurally unfair. The first respondent failed to show there was any chance that a fair dismissal would have occurred, so no Polkey reduction was applied.

Breach of Contractfailed

The claimant's contractual notice period was 12 weeks and the tribunal found he was given that full notice. No breach was established.

Redundancy Paypartly succeeded

The first respondent underpaid the claimant's statutory redundancy pay by £405. The tribunal awarded this shortfall.

Holiday Payfailed

The claimant failed to show there was an underpayment of holiday pay connected to commission payments. Even if there had been an underpayment, no award would have been made because the first respondent had overpaid the claimant in his final pay.

Facts

The claimant was employed by Yourway Transport Limited and was made redundant. He brought claims for age discrimination, unfair dismissal, breach of contract regarding notice, underpayment of statutory redundancy pay, and underpayment of holiday pay. The matter was heard over four days by video hearing.

Decision

The tribunal found the redundancy dismissal was unfair with no Polkey reduction. The age discrimination claim failed. The claimant was awarded the statutory cap on compensatory award (£93,878) plus £405 underpaid redundancy pay. Claims for notice pay and holiday pay failed.

Practical note

Where an employer cannot show any chance that a fair dismissal would have occurred following a redundancy, no Polkey reduction will be applied, and the claimant may recover the full statutory cap on compensatory award.

Award breakdown

Compensatory award£93,878
Redundancy pay£405

Case details

Case number
3308957/2022
Decision date
25 September 2025
Hearing type
full merits
Hearing days
4
Classification
contested

Respondent

Sector
transport
Represented
Yes
Rep type
barrister

Claimant representation

Represented
Yes
Rep type
barrister